Episode summary

Closing Bell panel weighs whether the selloff is a buying opportunity

CNBC Closing Bell · · Hosts: Joe Kernan, Kelly Evans, Rebecca Quick · Guests: Cameron Dawson, Kevin Gordon

Closing Bell panel weighs whether the selloff is a buying opportunity – CNBC Closing Bell

Summary

The panel argued that the sharp selloff may be close to a short-term tradable low, even if it is not necessarily the ultimate bottom. One analyst said the market looks oversold, pointing to the S&P 500 near 6926 versus an earlier 7000 support level, the VIX moving above 36, and a surge in put buying as signs of capitulation and fear.

But the same panel also warned that further downside is possible if earnings expectations have to come down. The other analyst said 2027 and 2028 earnings estimates look too high, and that compressed valuations in the S&P 500 and the SOX suggest the market is already anticipating cuts. That view was summed up with the idea that investors usually do not buy the first sign of a cut, but wait for the first actual estimate reduction.

On positioning, the discussion shifted to whether the broader market or the AI megacaps are driving sentiment. The panel noted that breadth was not as bad as the prior day, havens and bonds caught a bid, and much of this year’s P/E decline has been concentrated in tech. They also said retail buying into AI weakness complicates any simple washout signal.

Key takeaways

  • One analyst said the market is oversold enough for a short-term bounce, with fear gauges like the VIX above 36 and heavy demand for downside protection.
  • Another analyst argued the selloff is not necessarily the ultimate low because 2027 and 2028 earnings estimates still look too high.
  • The panel said valuations have compressed to about 17 times for the S&P 500 and 14 times for the SOX, which can reflect expectations for earnings cuts.
  • Kevin Gordon said investors should be wary of using valuations alone as a timing tool, since long-run market history shows little relationship to one-year forward returns.
  • The panel highlighted that AI megacaps and broader market sentiment may be diverging, with retail still adding to some AI names on weakness.

Notable quotes

“I DO THINK THAT WE ARE OVERSOLD ENOUGH FOR SOME KIND OF TACTICAL OR TACTICAL OR TRADABLE LOW IN THE MARKET”

— A speaker on CNBC Closing Bell at 0:38

“THE MARKET IS ACTUALLY TELLING YOU TODAY THAT THEY ARE TOO HIGH”

— A speaker on CNBC Closing Bell at 2:21

“YOU DON'T BUY IN ANTICIPATION OF THE CUT, YOU BUY THE FIRST CUT”

— A speaker on CNBC Closing Bell at 2:45

“TODAY'S A GOOD EXAMPLE OF, YOU KNOW, THE BREADTH SITUATION ACTUALLY NOT BEING HORRIBLE”

— A speaker on CNBC Closing Bell at 3:12

“NOTHING HAS BEEN A WORSE MARKET TIMING TOOL THAN VALUATIONS”

— A speaker on CNBC Closing Bell at 5:09

Topics

  • market selloff
  • oversold bounce
  • vix put-call ratio
  • s&p support levels
  • ai semiconductor weakness

Companies and tickers mentioned

  • AMD
  • Schwab Center for Financial Research
  • NewEdge Wealth
  • Advanced Micro Devices

Watch the episode

Watch “Closing Bell panel weighs whether the selloff is a buying opportunity” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from CNBC Closing Bell

All CNBC Closing Bell episodes →

CNBC Closing Bell, this episode and its artwork belong to CNBC. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.