Episode summary
Letting Winners Run: David Ryan And Chris Gessel On The Rules Driving The New FFTY
Summary
The episode focuses on the redesign of FFTY and related IBD strategies after the switch to Cap Force, with the main goal of making the products more faithful to the way leading stocks actually behave. The host, Chris Gessel, and David Ryan argue that the old weekly rebalancing framework punished strength by cutting winners back down too quickly, which made the ETF sluggish and often anti-IBD in practice. Ryan says the new approach is designed to let winners run, while still capping any single stock around 8% so no position dominates the portfolio.
The discussion also covers a major shift in stock selection: the new screen emphasizes composite rating plus relative strength, with a tiebreaker from EPS, instead of forcing more complex criteria. Gessel says backtesting showed that the screen captures most of the market’s big winners and that weaker markets naturally shrink the number of qualifying stocks, creating an automatic cash position and a built-in form of market timing.
They also preview future tweaks for BOUT and FFTY, including upper-channel-line exits, shorter-term moving-average sells, and possible limits on sector concentration. In the market wrap, Ryan argues the Nasdaq still looks damaged, while equal-weighted indexes and value are holding up better than growth.
Key takeaways
- Ryan says FFTY’s old structure was hurting performance by resetting strong stocks back to small weights every week.
- Gessel says the new stock screen uses composite rating plus relative strength, with EPS as a tiebreaker, to better capture the market’s leaders.
- Ryan says the new portfolio rules will allow individual names to grow to about 8% if they keep working, instead of capping upside too early.
- Gessel says weaker markets will naturally reduce the number of qualifying stocks, leaving more cash and creating automatic market timing.
- Ryan says the Nasdaq still looks weak, while equal-weighted and value-oriented indexes are holding up better than growth.
Notable quotes
“it would work okay in some markets, uh, when everything was moving, but when, you know, there were fewer leaders, then you're you're just kind of whacking the the the ETF at the knees”
“it's almost anti- O'Neal because he's always talking about you add to your winners and your winners should become a bigger part of your portfolio as time goes on”
“we want to let these things run, but we can't we can't let one individual stock become, you know, 30% of the portfolio”
“when the market is weak you get many fewer stocks into the screen of looking at composite and relative strength”
Topics
- letting winners run
- backtesting
- quality-first trading rules
- ffty
- bout
Companies and tickers mentioned
- Investors Business Daily
Watch the episode
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Investing With Ibd
Investing With Ibd, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.