Episode summary

You Can Seize Everything (The U.S. is reviving pirate law)

Planet Money · · Hosts: Nick Fountain · Guests: Sierra Juarez, Robert Rodriguez, Jimmy Keeley, Marianne McCune, Sam Yellowhorse Kesler, Alex Goldmark

You Can Seize Everything (The U.S. is reviving pirate law) – Planet Money

Summary

The episode examines how the U.S. is seizing oil tankers linked to Iran and Venezuela and then struggling with what to do next. Under the current system, the government uses civil asset forfeiture, which can take months or years and leaves the ship sitting in custody while maintenance costs pile up. In the Majestic X case, the DOJ spent $42 million on custody, maintenance, and repairs in the first month and a half, even though the government said the ship was worth less than $3 million.

To avoid that delay, the U.S. is reviving prize law, an old maritime regime from the age of privateers and prize courts. The episode explains that prize law is still on the books and could allow the government to condemn and sell seized vessels and cargo much faster, with modern rules being drafted for the Southern District of Texas. Those rules include evidence-gathering procedures, references to FBI and NCIS, and a carveout for perishable or hazardous goods like crude oil.

The biggest legal uncertainty is whether prize law applies without a formal declaration of war. A law professor says prize requires war, not just conflict, while the judge setting up the rules declined to adopt broader language and left that issue for litigation. The result could be a faster system, but also a fresh court fight over whether the U.S. is actually at war for prize purposes.

Key takeaways

  • The government says civil asset forfeiture is too slow and costly for seized oil tankers, especially when maintenance costs can quickly exceed a ship’s value.
  • Prize law would let the U.S. sell captured vessels and cargo much faster, but it is an antiquated system that has to be rebuilt for modern courts.
  • A law professor argues prize taking requires war, not just conflict, which could make the new system vulnerable to jurisdictional challenges.
  • The Southern District of Texas has drafted 30 pages of prize rules that include oil-specific procedures and modern tracking references.
  • The judge declined to rewrite the rules around the war question, leaving the key legal issue for future cases.

Notable quotes

“Prize law has ancient roots in maritime law and provides the framework to condemn, return, or dispose of maritime property seized in conflict”

— A speaker on Planet Money at 3:56

“the law of prize is still on the books, right? And it's still good law in the sense that we are allowed to take ships as prize”

— A speaker on Planet Money at 18:39

“a necessary precondition of taking prizes is that you are at war”

— A speaker on Planet Money at 19:35

“It seems like a much faster, more streamlined process than civil asset forfeite”

— A speaker on Planet Money at 24:51

Topics

  • prize law
  • privateers
  • government ship seizures
  • oil tanker sanctions
  • modern prize court

Watch the episode

Watch “You Can Seize Everything (The U.S. is reviving pirate law)” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from Planet Money

All Planet Money episodes →

Planet Money, this episode and its artwork belong to NPR. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.