Episode summary
Bull v. Bear: WMT Holiday Tailwinds Meet P/E Concerns Ahead of Earnings
Summary
Walmart heads into earnings with expectations for 4% year-over-year EPS growth to $0.64 a share and adjusted revenue above $186.5 billion, while analysts broadly remain positive and Stifel reiterated a buy with a $145 target. The discussion centered on whether the stock’s recent strength and premium valuation can be sustained if the company delivers another solid quarter and upbeat guidance.
The bullish case leaned on Walmart’s operational scale, low prices, supply-chain execution, and holiday tailwinds. One analyst pointed to lower gas prices as a potential boost to consumer spending and traffic, while also noting that Walmart may benefit from the same prepper and stocking-up behavior that has helped peers. The argument was that consumer commentary on the call could move the stock materially.
The bearish case focused on valuation and structure. Kevin Hincks argued Walmart has historically traded at a lower P/E and said the current multiple around 45.5 to 46 leaves room for disappointment unless newer businesses like digital advertising, marketplace, and membership income continue to prove out. The example trades reflected that split: a bullish December 125/145 call vertical for more time after earnings, and a low-debit bearish November put calendar aimed at exploiting implied-volatility differences near the 120 area.
Key takeaways
- Walmart is expected to report $0.64 a share on $186.5 billion in adjusted revenue, with same-store sales projected to rise less than 3%.
- The bullish view is that lower gas prices and holiday shopping could support traffic and sales commentary on the call.
- The bearish view is that Walmart’s trailing P/E of about 45.5 to 46 is hard to justify unless newer high-margin businesses keep scaling.
- One analyst’s bullish trade was a December 125/145 call vertical, designed to give the stock more time to work after earnings.
- The bearish trade used a November put calendar around 120 to take advantage of implied-volatility differences and hedge downside risk.
Notable quotes
“Earnings are expected to increase 4% on a year over year basis to $0.64 a share”
“Walmart has outperformed the broader market this year, but target has done even better”
“The first heroine is the gas prices are moving to the downside”
“the reason why I kind of bring up the technicals before the fundamentals is because of where the location of where the price is at right now”
“they have a history of trading at a much lower p e than the forward p e, the trailing p e they have right now of 45.5 to 46”
Topics
- walmart earnings
- options trades
- holiday tailwinds
- pe valuation concerns
- guidance
Companies and tickers mentioned
- WMT
- Walmart
Watch the episode
Watch “Bull v. Bear: WMT Holiday Tailwinds Meet P/E Concerns Ahead of Earnings” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Schwab Network
-
Thorne: Fed Rate Hike Talk “Irresponsible,” PANW Growth Too Slow -
NVDA "Generational" Buying Opportunity? Hatem Dhiab Offers Bull Case -
Wednesday's First Moves: GTA VI Release Ahead, LOW Earnings, NKE Lower -
Options Corner: PANW Earnings in Focus as Tech Outages Grip U.S. -
NVDA Earnings Raise Questions on Neocloud Funding; Mixed Housing Market Data -
NVDA Earnings "Non-Event?" Scott Bauer Remains Cautious on Stock
Schwab Network, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.