Episode summary

This Shocked Us (High Probability vs Low Probability)

Smb Capital ·

This Shocked Us (High Probability vs Low Probability) – Smb Capital

Summary

A backtested high-probability iron condor strategy produced more than $17,000 in profit over 6 years on $25,000 of planned capital, with relatively low drawdowns of about $5,600. But the host argues that the headline result hid a weakness: when trades were grouped by volatility, the low-VIX environment lost about $6,500, while the higher-VIX groups were profitable.

The episode lays out SMB Capital’s approach to strategy development as an 80/20 process. The first 80% is building a clear, repeatable plan for entries, adjustments, profit taking, and exits; the remaining 20% is looking for extra edge without curve fitting. Here, that meant keeping the iron condor mechanics unchanged and testing whether broad VIX regimes could explain the uneven results.

The comparison was simple: VIX below 15, 15 to 20, and above 20. The host says the low-VIX trades were the problem, and that filtering them out would have improved the backtest to $23,574, a roughly 94% return on planned capital. He cautions, though, that this improvement comes from historical filtering and still needs to be validated with information available at the time of entry.

Key takeaways

  • The host says the iron condor made more than $17,000 overall, but low-VIX trades lost about $6,500 and dragged down performance.
  • VIX above 20 and VIX between 15 and 20 were both profitable, while VIX below 15 had a lower win rate and negative expectancy.
  • The host argues that changing rules to optimize a backtest can create curve fitting; the better approach is to test whether a known strategy should be traded at all in certain conditions.
  • Skipping the low-VIX trades would have lifted historical profit to $23,574, but the host says that filter still needs real-time validation.
  • SMB Capital’s framework emphasizes a fixed plan for entries, adjustments, profit taking, and maximum loss before trying to add more edge.

Notable quotes

“We didn't change our entries. We didn't change our adjustments. We didn't change our exits. We simply looked at when the strategy performed best”

— A speaker on Smb Capital

“The first 80% is building a robust trade plan. We need clearly defined rules for entries, adjustments, profit taking and exits”

— A speaker on Smb Capital at 2:05

“The remaining 20% is looking for ways to improve the strategy without constantly changing the mechanics of the trade”

— A speaker on Smb Capital at 2:05

“But if we remove those trades of the lowest VIX group, our profit historically increases to $23,574”

— A speaker on Smb Capital at 10:59

“Sometimes improving a trading strategy isn't about finding more trades. It's about identifying the trades that might not be worth taking for this iron condor”

— A speaker on Smb Capital at 11:59

Topics

  • options strategy
  • iron condor
  • vix analysis
  • backtesting
  • curve fitting pitfalls

Watch the episode

Watch “This Shocked Us (High Probability vs Low Probability)” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from Smb Capital

All Smb Capital episodes →

Smb Capital, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.