Episode summary

Cem Karsan Called for a 25 to 40% Decline, and He Still Does

Tastylive · · Hosts: Tom Preston · Guests: Cem Karsan

Cem Karsan Called for a 25 to 40% Decline, and He Still Does – Tastylive

Summary

Cem Karsan argues the market is still in the middle of a structurally dangerous setup: macro risk has risen, but dealer flows and expiration dynamics are still delaying the full move. He says the market has been carrying a headwind since the midterms, and that bad news tends to matter only once the relevant open interest and hedges are forced to unwind, citing COVID in 2020 and the Russia-Ukraine setup in 2022 as examples of delayed rollover.

His core call remains unchanged: he has publicly said he expects a 25% to 40% decline between November and June, with the most likely window still December into January. He says the market needs a much larger, faster downside move to “activate” puts and create a true crash, but until then, VIX and vol compression can keep supporting price even as the macro weakens. He frames this as a forward distribution problem, not a simple bullish-or-bearish trade.

Karsan also dismisses the near-term Fed decision as mostly theater, saying a 25 basis-point move matters less than the broader credibility narrative and the likelihood of eventual easing. In his view, the bigger trade is to stay long tail risk and longer-dated volatility while expecting continued whipsaw into December opex and beyond.

Key takeaways

  • Karsan still expects a 25% to 40% decline from November to June, with December into January his highest-probability window.
  • He says the market needs a 10% or larger fast downside move to trigger the bigger put-driven air pocket.
  • He argues that near-term bad news can be absorbed by dealer flows until expiration pressure fades, citing COVID in 2020 and the 2022 rollover.
  • He views the Fed’s December decision as mostly a credibility exercise, not the main market driver.
  • He prefers expressing the trade as a forward distribution, staying long tail risk and longer-dated volatility rather than making a simple directional bet.

Notable quotes

“I've said that vocally that's a big call and a lot of people taking me out to the woodshed for it right and I've said that the like the most likely probability is December Jr”

— Cem Karsan at 5:24

“You are thinking about options trading wrong if you if you are saying that options are a forward distribution of outcomes”

— Cem Karsan at 6:07

“the flows are a massive headwind until de expiration really into the end of the year”

— Cem Karsan at 4:02

“we knew about COVID in December. We didn't turn over till Feb OPEX”

— Cem Karsan at 4:02

“I am much more long of implied volatility and paying out and scale December and January”

— Cem Karsan at 16:02

Topics

  • market drawdown
  • options hedging
  • open interest
  • volatility
  • macro timing

Watch the episode

Watch “Cem Karsan Called for a 25 to 40% Decline, and He Still Does” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from Tastylive

All Tastylive episodes →

Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.