Episode summary

How he beat the S&P 500 for 11 years doing (almost) nothing

My First Million · · Hosts: Shaan Puri, Sam Parr

How he beat the S&P 500 for 11 years doing (almost) nothing – My First Million

Summary

The episode centers on a public investor who reportedly averaged a 21.8% annual return over roughly 12 years while making only 2.9 stock decisions per year, including several years of zero activity. The hosts use that example to argue that great investing often looks like deep study, patience, and waiting for the right setup rather than constant trading. They contrast that with their own tendency to confuse motion with progress and note that the investor made decisions only when a stock entered his circle of competence and became cheap enough.

From there, the conversation broadens into decision-making principles. They discuss premortems, citing Jack Dorsey’s list of 140 reasons Square could fail, and compare investing’s emphasis on avoiding mistakes with entrepreneurship’s willingness to absorb many mistakes in pursuit of a few huge wins. Mark Zuckerberg’s recent public interviews come up as an example of strong leadership, talent density, and clear communication, especially around Meta’s AI push.

The second half turns personal: one host describes working with an executive coach, identifying the game he is actually playing, and learning a framework for handling panic attacks and claustrophobia through acceptance and exposure. The episode ends on the idea that in uncertainty, motion and preparation matter more than perfect certainty.

Key takeaways

  • The investor described in the episode beat the S&P 500 with a 21.8% annual return while making only 2.9 decisions a year.
  • The hosts argue that many top performers win by studying deeply, writing notes, and waiting for rare opportunities rather than trading constantly.
  • The episode says premortems help separate a bad result from a bad decision, with Jack Dorsey’s 140 reasons Square could fail as the example.
  • They frame Zuckerberg’s edge as strategic clarity, strong beliefs on execution, and an ability to recruit high-signal people quickly.
  • One host says identifying the game you are actually playing is a useful way to reduce comparison and self-criticism.
  • The DARE method for panic attacks is presented as dismiss, allow, run towards, and engage, with exposure and acceptance doing most of the work.

Notable quotes

“he only made 2.9 decisions a year. And we put together this cool graph and there were some years, I believe uh three out of the last 10 years, he made zero decisions”

— A speaker on My First Million

“his investment strategy is lethargy bordering on sloth that's like the cornerstone of his investment uh thesis”

— A speaker on My First Million

“for the ones that are reversible, don't sweat over them. Don't agonize over them”

— A speaker on My First Million at 7:55

“You got to keep your sales up”

— A speaker on My First Million at 41:00

“I act and the plan emerges from my action”

— A speaker on My First Million at 41:00

Topics

  • zero action investing
  • premortems
  • zuck victory lap
  • executive coaching
  • panic management

Watch the episode

Watch “How he beat the S&P 500 for 11 years doing (almost) nothing” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from My First Million

All My First Million episodes →

My First Million, this episode and its artwork belong to Hubspot Media. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.