Episode summary
Is It Too Late to Buy Protection Once the Selloff Starts?
Summary
The discussion argues that a selloff does not automatically make hedging too expensive or irrational. The host and a guest push back on the “buying insurance after the house is on fire” analogy, saying that in markets you do not know whether a drop will continue or reverse. Their view is that if an investor still sees downside risk after a move, buying protection can still make sense, especially through an at-the-money put spread rather than a naked out-of-the-money put.
They also distinguish between a modest volatility spike and true panic. The guest says 20 VIX is not 35 VIX, and that only in a much more extreme, already-panicked tape would the “house already burned down” analogy fit. On the premium-selling side, the guest says there is no fixed percentage of the account tied to a VIX level, but the higher and more stable volatility gets, the more capital can be allocated to iron condors and other neutral premium sales. The broader point is that trading requires keeping powder dry because volatility can jump fast, while investing is treated as a separate, always-deployed capital bucket.
Key takeaways
- The host and guest reject the idea that a post-drop hedge is automatically too late, because market direction from here is still uncertain.
- The guest prefers an at-the-money put spread over naked downside puts when hedging a continued selloff.
- A 20 VIX is not treated as panic; the guest says 35 VIX is closer to the point where protection becomes much less attractive.
- The guest says premium-selling size should increase gradually as VIX rises and stabilizes, not all at once.
- The discussion draws a sharp line between trading, where cash is held back for opportunity, and investing, where capital stays fully deployed.
Notable quotes
“With the market, you don't know what the rest of the day, week, month, quarter, year is going to bring”
“I don't love buying out of the money puts. Buy an at the money put spread or something like that”
“20 Vix is not 35 Vix. This was a 35 [clears throat] Vix, I'd be like, you know, the house has already burned down”
“when Vix is below 15, I don't even think about selling index ball”
“there's always capital set aside, powder dry, in the event that we can take advantage of an opportunity in front of us in the short term”
Topics
- vix hedge
- put spreads
- options premium
- downside protection
- volatility based position sizing
Watch the episode
Watch “Is It Too Late to Buy Protection Once the Selloff Starts?” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Tastylive
-
Nvidia Is Down 37% and Traders Can’t Agree What Happens Next -
Tim Knight Calls This the Great Sell-the-News Event -
Tim Knight Says Earnings Are Done, Data Is Done, and Nothing’s Left to Move It -
There's No Single Volatility Number for a Stock -
Markets Grind Higher and Crash Lower, and Here's the Proof -
NVIDIA SHOCK: Jensen Huang RESIGNS; NVDA -9% | THURSDAY Nov 12 Live Trading
Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.