Episode summary
The Day Before Thanksgiving Is Up 68% of the Time, the Day After Only 40%
Summary
The segment tests whether holiday superstition shows up in SPY returns, using full trading sessions from 1996 onward. The host compares ordinary days with Friday the 13th, Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Independence Day, looking at the share of positive sessions, average and median returns, and trading volume. The broad market baseline over the sample is 53.7% positive days, with small average and median gains.
Friday the 13th does not look bearish in the data. The host says SPY was up almost 58% of those sessions, better than an average Friday, though the sample is only 52 observations. He argues Fridays can be supported by a lighter event calendar and monthly expiration activity, which may create a slight positive drift.
The holiday pattern is strongest around Thanksgiving and July 4th. SPY is up 68% of the sessions before Thanksgiving but only 40% after, while Independence Day shows a similar flip from 71% before to 35% after, with a slightly negative average return afterward. Christmas is the exception: strength remains high on both sides of the holiday. Volume generally falls around these periods, with the sharpest slowdown after Christmas.
Key takeaways
- The host says Friday the 13th was not bearish; SPY was positive on almost 58% of those sessions versus 53.7% for all days.
- Before Thanksgiving, SPY was up 68% of the time, but after Thanksgiving that dropped to 40%, according to the host’s 1996-to-2026 sample.
- Independence Day showed a similar reversal, with 71% positive sessions before the holiday and only 35% after.
- Christmas was the exception: the host says returns stayed strong before and after the holiday, unlike Thanksgiving and July 4th.
- Holiday trading volume was usually lighter than average, and the host says the biggest slowdown came after Christmas.
Notable quotes
“Friday the 13th actually cause the market to go down because of superstitions and then what happens you know during other market holidays”
“we're going to use SPY uh full trading day sessions since 1996”
“SPY has had been positive on 53.7% of those days so 54% of the days”
“there's 57 almost 58% up days that happened on the market on Friday the 13th specifically”
“67% up days before and then only 40 40% on the day after”
Topics
- stock market seasonality
- thanksgiving week trading
- friday the 13th effect
- independence day market pattern
- christmas seasonality
Watch the episode
Watch “The Day Before Thanksgiving Is Up 68% of the Time, the Day After Only 40%” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Tastylive
-
The Anthropic IPO Went Fine But Stocks Collapsed. What's Going On? -
The Last Time This Setup Appeared, Stocks Lost 25% Into Christmas -
Danielle Shay Isn't Convinced This Low Is In -
The Headline Says Up 15%, Anyone Who Bought the Open Is Down 20% -
Nancy Davis: If It Trades Down, People Should Be Worried -
Lance Breitstein Put In for $10 Million of Shares and Got Zero
Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.