Episode summary
The Last Time This Setup Appeared, Stocks Lost 25% Into Christmas
Summary
Carley Garner argues the dollar’s recent rally is the central macro signal, because a stronger dollar tends to weigh on stocks and commodities and push investors toward liquidity. She says the dollar index held support in a 20-year trading range, sentiment was extremely bearish, and the move is echoing Trump 1.0 closely enough that she thinks the rally could extend toward 110 or even 113 if recession risk rises.
That dollar view leads her to a bearish read on precious metals. Garner says gold and silver have been “treacherous” in 2026, with metals behaving more like risk assets than classic hedges, and she thinks the cycle could leave them dead money for 5 to 10 years. She points to downside targets around 3650 and 3300 for gold, but says traders should be cautious because holiday markets can move violently in either direction.
She also sees a possible repeat of 2018 in equities: a rate hike in September, another priced for December, and a market that kept buying the dip until the S&P 500 lost 25% from the highs. Garner thinks the same setup is developing now, which would pressure copper too, since the AI-driven copper story has been too crowded and too dependent on stock-market momentum.
Key takeaways
- Garner says the dollar is following the Trump 1.0 roadmap and could still run to 110 or 113 if risk aversion deepens.
- Garner thinks a stronger dollar is a headwind for most stocks and commodities because it makes U.S. assets less attractive abroad.
- Garner says gold and silver have behaved like risk assets in 2026 and may stay dead money for 5 to 10 years if the dollar keeps rising.
- Garner argues the market is repeating 2018’s Fed-and-stocks pattern, when rate hikes helped trigger a 25% S&P drawdown.
- Garner says copper’s AI narrative became overcrowded, and a sell-the-rallies tape could push it sharply lower, possibly toward $4.
Notable quotes
“If that continues the dollar rally is nowhere near being complete. In fact, we probably go, my best guess is we probably go to uh 110, maybe even 113”
“a higher dollar is a headwind for most stocks, most commodities, and I think it kind of changes the environment from what we saw a year or so ago where buying the dips was uh what worked”
“I don't recall ever seeing a market complex uh do as much damage as I've seen the metals do this year to retail traders”
“Gold and silver, they're the type of markets that do nothing for five, 10 years and then they do everything in one and two years”
“we went into December, the stock market uh realized that there the Fed was in fact going to lower, I'm sorry, raise rates again in December of 2018. Stocks took a 25% haircut from the recent highs”
Topics
- dollar outlook
- metals trading
- why metals go dead
- 2018 market parallel
- copper misconceptions
Companies and tickers mentioned
- DeCarley Trading
Watch the episode
Watch “The Last Time This Setup Appeared, Stocks Lost 25% Into Christmas” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Tastylive
-
The Headline Says Up 15%, Anyone Who Bought the Open Is Down 20% -
Nancy Davis: If It Trades Down, People Should Be Worried -
Lance Breitstein Put In for $10 Million of Shares and Got Zero -
Yesterday Was the Most Negative Positioning on Record and He's Bullish -
The Day Before Thanksgiving Is Up 68% of the Time, the Day After Only 40% -
Anthropic IPO: What Happened to SpaceX and Meta on Day One?
Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.