Episode summary
Trump Warned of a Depression, Here’s What the Options Actually Price
Summary
The episode pushes back on Donald Trump’s warning of an economic depression if Democrats win the midterms by asking what the options market is actually pricing. The host argues that the historical equity pattern around midterms is mixed but not party-deterministic, with gridlock often associated with better stock outcomes than one-party control.
Using SPX levels around 7,803, the host says a depression would imply a 20% downside move, but the January options market only implies an expected move of about 423 points, or a little over 5% in either direction. Even looking much farther out, the host says the pricing reflects movement, not a one-way crash, and that protecting against a 20% drop is possible but expensive.
The same conclusion is drawn from volatility: the VIX is around 15, and the VIX futures curve is in contango, which the host says does not show elevated fear around the election. The overall argument is that the headlines are dramatic, but options and volatility are not signaling a depression or even a large crash.
Key takeaways
- The host says the options market is not pricing in a depression, because January SPX options imply about a 423-point move, or a little over 5%, in either direction.
- The host says a true depression-style move would mean roughly a 20% drop in the S&P 500, which is far beyond current implied movement.
- The host says buying protection against a 20% crash is possible, but the put premium and break-even make it expensive.
- The host says the VIX around 15 and a contango term structure do not show election-related fear.
- The host says gridlock has historically been good for stocks, even if the exact statistics vary by definition.
Notable quotes
“let's forget about politics and look at the calendar. Let's go way back. Since 1950, the midterm year averages just 4.6%”
“You can see 423 points. Now, again, that's that's either direction. Point being, there's no depression certainly being priced in”
“Even if you go out to uh let's say January of 2028. Well, now you're looking at 1,200 points. That's something of close to maybe 20%”
Topics
- options pricing
- spx expected move
- vix volatility
- depression definition
- crash hedge costs
Watch the episode
Watch “Trump Warned of a Depression, Here’s What the Options Actually Price” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Tastylive
-
Nvidia Is Down 37% and Traders Can’t Agree What Happens Next -
Tim Knight Calls This the Great Sell-the-News Event -
Tim Knight Says Earnings Are Done, Data Is Done, and Nothing’s Left to Move It -
There's No Single Volatility Number for a Stock -
Markets Grind Higher and Crash Lower, and Here's the Proof -
NVIDIA SHOCK: Jensen Huang RESIGNS; NVDA -9% | THURSDAY Nov 12 Live Trading
Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.