Episode summary
I Thought Oil Would Go to the Moon. I Was Wrong | Art Berman
Summary
Art Berman argues that oil pricing is better understood as a system of stocks, buffers, and adaptation than as a simple supply-and-demand equation. He says supply and demand can line up with price in short episodes like COVID or the financial crisis, but over the last 25 years supply-demand balance has had zero correlation to oil price, while comparative inventory — current stocks versus the five-year average — has worked about 80% of the time.
Using that framework, he says the market is paying attention to inventories and to how long the Iran conflict is likely to last, not just to dramatic headlines about the Strait of Hormuz. He argues that strategic petroleum reserve drawdowns matter less to price than many people think, because the system has adapted through commercial inventories, rerouted tankers, and high U.S. output near 14 million barrels a day. He estimates those workarounds have added about $35 a barrel to the cost of moving oil.
Berman also rejects the idea that China’s falling imports are mostly about EV adoption or a political bargain. He says the likelier explanation is weaker Chinese demand, backed by lower refinery runs. Looking ahead, he thinks oil may stay in a higher-for-longer range until prices are high enough to force demand lower, and he says integrated oil companies are the first place he would look for investment ideas.
Key takeaways
- Art Berman says supply-demand balance has zero correlation to oil price over the last 25 years, while comparative inventory has worked about 80% of the time.
- Berman thinks markets are pricing a longer Iran conflict, not a quick resolution, which keeps oil elevated.
- He says U.S. and global system buffers — reserves, tankers, routing changes and production near 14 million barrels a day — have prevented a $200 oil blowout.
- Berman argues China’s weaker oil imports are most likely a demand problem, not mainly EV adoption or stockpiling.
- He says the higher oil price now includes roughly a $35-a-barrel logistics premium from moving crude through a more complicated system.
- For investors, Berman says integrated oil companies are the best starting point because they see refining, production and distribution as one system.
Notable quotes
“Supply demand balance has zero correlation to price over the last 25 years because it works sometimes and it makes sense that it should work”
“what oil markets pay attention to, whoever they are, I mean, they're us and a lot of other, you know, what is a market? It pays attention to inventories”
“I have used a method for 25 years which is called comparative inventory”
“I mean, we're very close to 14 million barrels a day”
“the simplest reason or way to understand higher oil prices is all those things have contributed a premium to oil price which is roughly $35 a barrel”
Topics
- oil prices
- supply vs demand
- comparative inventory
- iran shipping disruption
- chinese oil demand
Watch the episode
Watch “I Thought Oil Would Go to the Moon. I Was Wrong | Art Berman” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Wealthion
-
Before You Buy the Dip, Ask These 3 Questions -
Your Gains Are at Risk: What Albert Lu Would Hold Before the Next Drop -
Steve Hanke Warns: A Financial Crisis Could Send Stocks Down 40% -
The Energy Supercycle Could Last Into the 2030s | Josef Schachter -
Why Treasury Bonds Could Beat Stocks in 2027 | Keith McCullough -
The Credit Market Warning That Could Hit Stocks | Jeff Snider
Wealthion, this episode and its artwork belong to Wealthion. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.