Episode summary

The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This 2018 Again?

Excess Returns · · Hosts: Matt Zeigler · Guests: Barry Knapp

The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This 2018 Again? – Excess Returns

Summary

Barry Knapp argues that the Fed is tightening into slowing earnings growth, making the current setup look more like 2018 than a healthy soft landing. His main critique is that policymakers are misreading inflation: they are focused on goods-price pressures from energy, tariffs, and AI demand, while the stronger inflation impulse is coming from fiscal policy and services. He says rate hikes and passive balance-sheet policy are still lower long-term financing costs for large borrowers while squeezing small banks, small businesses, and homebuilders.

He also says the labor market is weakening in a way that matters for productivity. In his view, labor churn has fallen sharply from the post-pandemic reallocation, and that lower turnover makes it harder for wages and productivity to rise. On AI, he argues that adoption is real but slower than bulls expect, and that the big hyperscalers have likely already seen peak capex growth and peak earnings growth tied to the buildout.

That said, Knapp does not see a recession as the base case. He thinks a broader capex cycle could still develop if policy becomes less distorted, tax incentives remain supportive, and investment spreads beyond AI into manufacturing, industrials, and smaller businesses. His portfolio stance reflects that balance: cash remains elevated, consumer-facing sectors are underweight, and financials, industrials, materials, and energy remain preferred exposures.

Key takeaways

  • Knapp says the Fed is tightening into slowing earnings growth, which makes the setup look tactically similar to 2018.
  • He argues inflation is mostly a fiscal phenomenon, while the Fed is misdiagnosing it as goods-price pressure from energy, tariffs, and AI demand.
  • He says the Fed’s balance-sheet policy still subsidizes large borrowers while raising the cost of capital for small banks, homebuilders, and mom-and-pop businesses.
  • Knapp believes labor churn has fallen to levels associated with weak wage growth and weak productivity, creating a fragile labor backdrop.
  • He says AI capex growth at the big four hyperscalers has likely peaked and slowed from about 125% to around 60%, with earnings growth also decelerating.
  • His positioning remains cautious: elevated cash, underweight consumer sectors, and an emphasis on financials and industrials over expensive defensives like staples.

Notable quotes

“The Fed is tightening into slowing earnings growth. This is decidedly similar to what happened in 2018”

— Barry Knapp

“Inflation is always and everywhere mostly a fiscal phenomenon that becomes a real problem when the Fed facilitates it”

— Barry Knapp at 59:42

“We've already had peak um capex in the AI infrastructure buildout. We've had peak earnings growth related to this”

— Barry Knapp at 36:31

Topics

  • fed tightening
  • earnings growth slowdown
  • ai capital spending
  • labor market churn
  • portfolio positioning

Companies and tickers mentioned

  • Ironsides Macroeconomics

Watch the episode

Watch “The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This 2018 Again?” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from Excess Returns

All Excess Returns episodes →

Excess Returns, this episode and its artwork belong to Excess Returns. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.