Episode summary
Martin Roth, CEO, Pensionskasse Manor: Bullish on Alts — But the Challenges Are Real
Summary
Martin Roth says Pensionskasse Manor runs a deliberately different model from most Swiss pension funds: fixed income is below 10%, and most capital is placed into alternatives such as private equity, infrastructure, hedge funds and gold. He argues that this only works when the board, investment committee and team all support the philosophy, because alternatives are illiquid and expensive, and the institution must be aligned from top to bottom.
Roth frames his biggest lessons around discipline rather than prediction. He says 90% of results are strategy-driven, that investors should avoid losses rather than try to maximize returns, and that market timing is generally a bad tool. He points to the 2008 crisis as proof that long-term money should stay committed to its strategy even when coverage ratios fall below 100%.
Looking ahead, he sees hedge funds still attractive, especially macro, quant and long-short managers, while warning that AI-related enthusiasm may be creating a bubble in equities. In private equity, he favors steady annual commitments, broad diversification, and secondaries as a way to reduce the J-curve and capture discounts. He would invest a hypothetical $10 billion much the same way: broadly diversified, with real assets, alternatives and limited fixed income.
Key takeaways
- Martin Roth says Pensionskasse Manor keeps fixed income below 10% and uses alternatives as the core of a diversified, all-weather portfolio.
- Roth argues that alternatives only work when the board, investment committee and team all support the strategy from top to bottom.
- He says 90% of investment results are strategy-driven, and younger CIOs should focus on risk control and avoiding losses.
- Roth sees hedge funds as attractive in the current environment, especially macro, quant and liquid long-short strategies.
- In private equity, he favors steady annual commitments and says the fund targets an additional 3% per year versus public markets.
- Roth would not chase a $10 billion windfall with a new playbook; he would invest it broadly the same way as the pension fund.
Notable quotes
“I think it's really a philosophy that needs to be supported from top to down”
“One should always consider that 90% of your results are strategy driven”
“Diversification is key. Every asset class, every region has it good years and it bad years”
“the return of your portfolio somehow is sometimes it's just a coincidence. The risk management is not”
How the episode opens
How are you able to take that risk? Because when you invest in alternatives, it's obviously illquid. So you cannot get your capital instantly and in such an environment that's a very natural question to come up. How are you able to take so much risk?
First of all, I think it's really a philosophy that needs to be supported from top to down. Meaning the board of directors need to stand behind such a strategy. the investment committee my team.
So it's really an alignment of interest to invest and to explore this kind of asset class. That's absolutely key. I would never go with an alternative quote of 20% as we do have if my board of director would be very critical.
So it's really a mindset on every level of the pension fund. One asset class I'm interested in is digital assets. Probably not bitcoins etc.
Uh so far uh of course you can talk about long short strategies etc. Bitcoins could be a part of digital assets but I think royalities uh could be something that would be could become very interesting. Each participating in the cash flow of streaming rights being for films, music etc.
markets change at the moment that dramatically. Uh I think macro is uh is still a very interesting testing uh style to invest in. Same goes for the quants and you see a lot of new models being developed with AI intelligence inside etc.
The results so far look quite interesting and also when it comes to the tact to the classical long short I think that there's also space for those kind of uh managers. Although I have to say see slowly but surely a bit a change of generation in the long short manager. So the so-called dinosaurs uh they might have these days a bit more pain in adapting to the current markets that maybe some younger talent that is used to trade in a in very volatile very uh fast changing uh equity markets.
From the episode’s captions: roughly the first two minutes, lightly cleaned. Keep watching on YouTube →
Topics
- alternative investments
- diversification
- hedge funds
- private equity
- risk management
Companies and tickers mentioned
- Pensionskasse Manor
Watch the episode
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Markets Group
-
The €3bn German Allocator Who Said No to Alternatives -
RE West 2026: Valerie Red Horse Mohl of the California Endowment Spoke to Courtney McQuade -
RE West 2026: Steve Biggs of The Mather Group Spoke to Courtney McQuade -
RE West 2026: Martha Delgado of Saint Francis Foundation Spoke to Courtney McQuade -
Two Stints as Interim CIO: Howard Hodel on Risk, Rebalancing and Reassuring the Board -
Stefan Beiner on Repo, Resilience, and Why Governance Beats Prediction in Pension Investing
Markets Group, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.
