Episode summary
I Tested Every 0DTE Profit Target Since 2012
Summary
The host backtests 20-delta SPX short put spreads that are $20 wide and compares four management styles: taking profits at 25%, 50%, 75%, or holding to expiration. The central trade-off is simple: faster exits produce a lower average dollar P&L but a much higher win rate, while holding longer can boost average profit at the cost of bigger intraday swings and larger worst-case losses.
At a 25% profit target, the host says the win rate is about 96% and trades usually last less than an hour, with median exits around 30 to 40 minutes. Pushing the target higher raises average P&L, but the win rate falls to roughly 92% at 50%, 88% at 75%, and 84% if held to expiration. The host also argues that efficiency matters: 25% has the best P&L per hour because the trade is closed so quickly.
For his own style, the host leans toward 50% on put spreads, while preferring 25% to 30% on iron condors. He notes that the data goes back to 2012 and that traders should choose a profit target that matches how much intraday volatility they can tolerate, then stick to it rather than reacting to every ugly day.
Key takeaways
- The host says 25% profit-taking on $20-wide 20-delta put spreads produced about a 96% win rate, the highest of the tested exits.
- The host found that 50% exits balance better P&L with still-high success, which is why he personally prefers about 50% on put spreads.
- The host says faster exits improve P&L per hour because most 25% winners close in less than an hour.
- The host argues that holding to expiration raises average P&L but also increases drawdowns, volatility, and the chance that a winner turns into a loser.
- The host says iron condors should use smaller profit targets, around 25% to 30%, because their credit is larger and they take longer to manage.
Notable quotes
“So for post right today I'm going to manage the position at 25% 50% 75% and also hold expiration”
“average hours in a trade for 25% is less than an hour and the median is only 30 to 40 minutes”
“I probably going to choose somewhere close to 50% for for the put spread”
“faster profit target, you're going to have lower P&L, you're going to have high higher success rate and you're going to lower tear risk”
Topics
- 0dte profit targets
- put spread profit-taking
- options backtesting
- intraday volatility
- drawdowns
Watch the episode
Watch “I Tested Every 0DTE Profit Target Since 2012” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Tastylive
-
Why the $157M Intel Put Trade Isn't What You Think -
Nasdaq 100: Why Your Year-End Target Might Be Misleading -
Jim Schultz Says Selling the VIX Outright Is a Really Bad Idea -
Brent Kochuba Says Put Positioning Hasn’t Been This Negative Since April 2025 -
The Anthropic IPO Went Fine But Stocks Collapsed. What's Going On? -
The Last Time This Setup Appeared, Stocks Lost 25% Into Christmas
Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.