Episode summary
Jim Schultz Says Selling the VIX Outright Is a Really Bad Idea
Summary
Jim Schultz framed the session around a brutal risk-off day, with the NASDAQ down about 980 points and gold falling alongside equities. He argued that gold’s low beta and low correlation do not make it a reliable safe haven when selling hits everything at once. In his view, days like this show why portfolio diversifiers can fail exactly when investors expect them to help.
The main lesson was about selling volatility, but not by trading volatility products directly. Schultz said selling the VIX outright or shorting volatility futures creates too much asymmetric downside, because volatility can spike far beyond what traders expect. Instead, he pushed using defined-risk option spreads on underlyings like SPY, where traders can still express a short-vol view while capping losses.
He illustrated that with put spreads and call spreads, focusing on vega rather than delta. Schultz emphasized that the spread structure makes the trader net short vega, so the position can benefit if implied volatility contracts, while limiting the damage if volatility keeps rising.
Key takeaways
- Jim Schultz said gold’s 0.2 beta and roughly 0.3 correlation did not protect investors on a day when gold fell about as much as the NASDAQ.
- Schultz argued that selling the VIX outright is a bad trade because the upside risk is asymmetric and volatility can still spike sharply.
- He said short vertical spreads let traders get net short vega without taking the open-ended risk of naked volatility selling.
- Schultz favored defined-risk structures like short put spreads and short call spreads for newer traders.
- He said a short put spread can benefit both from a market rebound and from implied volatility contracting.
Notable quotes
“gold is not a safe haven today. Gold is down more than the NASDAQ on a percentage basis”
“selling the VIX outright, not going to make any sense”
“the risk return is so asymmetrically against you”
Topics
- gold beta
- gold correlation
- selling vix outright
- shorting volatility
- options put spread
Watch the episode
Watch “Jim Schultz Says Selling the VIX Outright Is a Really Bad Idea” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from Tastylive
-
Why the $157M Intel Put Trade Isn't What You Think -
I Tested Every 0DTE Profit Target Since 2012 -
Nasdaq Plunges 3.5% as the AI Trade Unravels | Friday Nov 20 Live Trading -
Brent Kochuba Says Put Positioning Hasn’t Been This Negative Since April 2025 -
The Anthropic IPO Went Fine But Stocks Collapsed. What's Going On? -
The Last Time This Setup Appeared, Stocks Lost 25% Into Christmas
Tastylive, this episode and its artwork belong to their owners. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.