Episode summary

The Three Poisons Behind the Sell-Off | Andy Constan on Why This Dip Is Different

Excess Returns · · Hosts: Justin Carbonneau, Jack Forehand · Guests: Andy Constan

The Three Poisons Behind the Sell-Off | Andy Constan on Why This Dip Is Different – Excess Returns

Summary

Andy Constan argues that markets are being hit by three reinforcing pressures: companies are funding AI and other capex with more borrowing and equity issuance, buybacks are fading as a source of demand, and high rates are staying high long enough to matter. In his view, that combination shifts the market from an optimistic growth regime toward a growth scare, with the S&P 500 and the broader AI trade starting to reflect more realistic earnings expectations.

He says the buyback backdrop is changing because corporations can no longer comfortably do both capex and repurchases, while new IPOs and issuance add supply that investors must absorb. He also argues that government deficits are a major source of corporate profits, but with deficits no longer growing, that support to earnings is flattening. On rates, he thinks the difference now is persistence: higher borrowing costs have stayed elevated for months, which can slow housing, spending, and eventually the economy.

Constan remains optimistic about AI’s capabilities, but not about its pricing or returns. He says his outlook would improve only if real companies start generating profits or layoffs from token use at unsubsidized prices, because that would prove AI is creating durable economic value rather than just financial enthusiasm.

Key takeaways

  • Andy Constan thinks the market is being hit by three poisons at once: heavier borrowing, weaker buyback demand, and persistently high rates.
  • He says corporations have had to choose between capex and share repurchases, and many have reduced buybacks while issuing more stock.
  • Constan argues that government deficits support profits, but flat deficits mean less incremental help for corporate earnings.
  • He sees the current sell-off as the start of a growth scare, not yet a full slowdown, but one that could become more serious if equities stay weak for months.
  • He wants proof that AI can generate unsubsidized profits or measurable layoffs before he upgrades his view on the trade.

Notable quotes

“Corporations have no longer been able to afford both their capex and their share buyback. So, one had to go and they canled share buyback”

— Andy Constan

“Deficit spending growing creates earnings growth. Deficit spending flatline creates flatline earnings. Deficit spending falling creates a drag on profits”

— Andy Constan at 33:29

“I'm very optimistic about the capabilities of AI. I just don't know about the pricing”

— Andy Constan

Topics

  • ai financing
  • stock supply buybacks and issuance
  • persistent high interest rates
  • government deficits and corporate profits
  • wealth effect slowdown

Companies and tickers mentioned

  • Damped Spring

Watch the episode

Watch “The Three Poisons Behind the Sell-Off | Andy Constan on Why This Dip Is Different” on YouTube

Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.

More from Excess Returns

All Excess Returns episodes →

Excess Returns, this episode and its artwork belong to Excess Returns. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.