Episode summary
Why housing permits are near COVID lows
Summary
Housing starts were reported as a headline beat, but Logan Mohtashami said the more important signal was that housing permits looked terrible and have been deteriorating for years. He argued the current slowdown fits a longer pattern that began when rates rose, and said the key question is whether single-family permits drift back toward the COVID-era lows over the next year.
Mohtashami stressed that new-home construction and existing-home sales are very different markets. He said builders are efficient sellers, often using rate buydowns to keep new-home sales near 2019 levels, while the existing-home market is where most inventory growth happens. In his view, builder confidence data are skewed toward smaller builders and do not fully capture how large public builders manage supply.
He also pushed back on the idea of a massive national housing shortage, saying the builder sector has never been able to outbuild the existing-home market or sustain millions of completed units for sale. Demographics matter, he said, but population growth slowing later in the decade will make the builder model harder, not easier. On rates, he said the market is still waiting for the Fed and inflation outlook to settle before housing can reaccelerate.
Key takeaways
- Mohtashami said housing permits are the weak link, and single-family permits are not far from the COVID-era low.
- He argued builders are keeping new-home sales near 2019 levels by using rate buydowns and managing supply tightly.
- Mohtashami said the existing-home market, not builders, drives most U.S. inventory growth.
- He rejected a 10 million-home shortage narrative, saying builders have never been able to get completed units of sale above 200,000 for six decades.
- He said slower population growth later in the decade will make it harder for builders to compete with the existing-home market.
Notable quotes
“the housing permits were just look terrible and this has been happening for years now”
“we go to the CO 19 recession lows uh uh over the next year”
“the builder's confidence index that a lot of people use that we write in the articles that's tilted to small builders, not the big publicly traded builders”
“I think the last number was 111,000 or 113,000. Um, so that completed units of sale has been falling”
“the builders have never been able to get completed units of sale above 200,000 for six decades”
Topics
- housing permits
- housing construction
- builder confidence
- mortgage rates
- nonbank mortgage firms
Watch the episode
Watch “Why housing permits are near COVID lows” on YouTube
Summary, takeaways and quote selection by Octagon. Quotes are short excerpts; the full conversation is in the episode.
More from HousingWire Daily
HousingWire Daily, this episode and its artwork belong to HousingWire. Octagon is not affiliated with the show; this page is an independent summary.